Furmanoid wrote: ↑Thu Oct 22, 2020 10:29 amOK, what is the point of the rule? Explain how it isn’t arbitrary? Where does the eleven number come from? And if we are so awesome, why be so excited that we don’t have to face the Citadel? We should be chomping at the bit to play them! You can’t be talking about winning championships and at the same time express relief that you dodged to bellhops for goodness sakes!The Jackal wrote: ↑Thu Oct 22, 2020 8:53 amHow is it pointless?Furmanoid wrote: ↑Thu Oct 22, 2020 8:12 amJust because the rule is pointless in this instance. It is temporarily obsolete. It seems like the purpose of the rule is to allow at least a little time for school during fall semester. Or maybe it is intended to limit wear and tear on the body. With a 4 game schedule the hops have plenty of time to finish their coloring books, and that whole wear and tear thing has been thrown out the window. Maybe it was intended to support the fall playoff schedule that didn’t happen. “11” is just an arbitrary number at this point so give them a waiver. I want to go to that game.The Jackal wrote: ↑Thu Oct 22, 2020 6:27 am
Again, based on what, exactly?
It's easy to say "waiver," but you have to have a reason for it. What is their reason for a waiver?
What if they had played 11 games? 7? Would the NCAA approve a waiver for another 8 games in the spring? Were they somehow duped into thinking that the SoCon wouldn't play a conference schedule - a contingency that apparently everyone else in the conference anticipated but the Citadel?
Is the NCAA going to start handing out waivers to schools that want to play more than their allotted games so they can add more revenue? Just because?
And we better hope more teams start making greedy decisions based on $$$ or we won’t have anybody to play pretty soon.
Your argument appears to be that you feel the 11 game figure is arbitrary, despite the fact that every FCS program in the country is operating under the same rules.
At bottom, the Citadel is arguing for an exception to the rule based on nothing more than they feel they deserve one. That's ludicrous.
If you suck, you worry about Citadel. If not, you want to play them.
It isn’t a matter of deserving a waiver. It’s more a matter of what reason is there for not giving them one? What harm would be done?
Out of your list of peculiar arguments, this one is perhaps the most bizarre.
FCS teams cannot play more than 11 games. That's the rule unless there are certain seasons where a 12th game is permitted (based on the start of the season). This is not one of those seasons.
By your definition, any sports schedule is arbitrary and subject to change based on one team's feeling. Baseball playing 162 or NFL playing 16 games. All arbitrary and subject to change. I would wager that every sport in the country, from high school to college, has a cap on how many contests are permitted.
It absolutely is about deserving a waiver. That's the entire point of a waiver - you have a circumstance that allows you to except the rule. That applies whether it deals with eligibility, transfers, or, in this case, playing in excess of the number of games.
This is not the SoCon's fault. It's not the NCAA's fault. The Citadel made their decision and now will deal with the consequence of that decision. In a season where everything is upside down, they decided to act alone and in their best interest. In doing so, they will forfeit the right to compete for a conference title.
As a Furman fan, I'd love to see us play the Citadel. It's unfortunate that the Citadel made decisions that cost everyone the opportunity for that game.